Religion
January 6, 2026

How to Talk to Your Pastor About Politics

A pastoral guide for faithful and fruitful conversations
Written by
Tanner DiBella

Few topics create as much tension in the Church today as politics. Many church members feel a growing burden when cultural and moral issues go unaddressed. Many pastors feel an equally heavy weight as they seek to shepherd diverse congregations in a polarized age. Bridging that gap requires more than passion. It requires wisdom, humility, and love rooted in Scripture.

This is not about turning the Church into a political organization. It is about recognizing that behind every policy is a person, and shepherding people requires biblical clarity about the world they are navigating. Here is how to approach that conversation faithfully.

Begin With the Heart, Not the Argument

Before initiating any conversation, pause and examine your heart. Scripture teaches that our words reveal what is already forming inside us. Ask yourself why this matters so deeply to you. Is it frustration, fear, or a desire to be heard, or is it genuine concern for people and for the spiritual health of the Church.

When conversations are driven by anxiety or anger, they tend to produce defensiveness. When they are rooted in love for Christ and His people, they carry a different tone. The goal is not to win a debate but to strengthen the witness of the Church.

Lead With Honor for Pastoral Authority

Pastors carry an unseen burden. They are responsible for teaching truth, guarding unity, caring for wounded people, navigating legal realities, and answering to God for the souls entrusted to them. Scripture repeatedly calls believers to honor those who shepherd them.

Begin the conversation with gratitude. Acknowledge your pastor’s faithfulness to Scripture and their care for the congregation. Honor creates trust. Without it, even well intentioned concerns can sound like accusations.

Ask Thoughtful Questions Instead of Making Accusations

A confrontational posture closes doors quickly. A curious posture opens them. Instead of asking why certain topics are avoided, ask how your pastor thinks about addressing cultural issues biblically. Invite them to share their perspective, concerns, and convictions.

Jesus often taught by asking questions, not because He lacked answers, but because questions invite reflection. Asking allows pastors to articulate their pastoral reasoning rather than feel pressured to defend themselves.

Frame the Conversation Biblically, Not Partisanly

If the Church speaks only in political language, it loses its distinct voice. When you bring up issues like abortion, immigration, sexuality, elections, or voting, ground the conversation in Scripture.

Talk about the sanctity of life, the dignity of the human person, God’s design for the body and family, and the biblical call to justice and righteousness. Make it clear that you are not asking for endorsements or party alignment. You are asking for discipleship. The Church exists to form consciences, not to campaign.

Remember That Policies Affect Real People

Policies are not abstract. They shape the lives of women facing unplanned pregnancies, children in schools, families navigating broken systems, and communities impacted by law and leadership. Teaching on these issues is not political activism. It is pastoral care.

Helping believers think biblically about public life equips them to love their neighbors wisely. Silence does not protect people from confusion. Shepherding helps them navigate it.

Share Your Burden, Not Just Your Opinion

One of the most powerful ways to communicate is through personal testimony. Share why these issues matter to you. Perhaps you have walked alongside someone in a crisis pregnancy. Perhaps you have wrestled deeply with questions of identity, family, or civic responsibility.

When you speak vulnerably, the conversation shifts from ideology to discipleship. Pastors shepherd people, not positions. Personal stories invite pastoral concern rather than institutional resistance.

Be Patient With Process and Timing

Even when a pastor agrees with the substance of your concern, change often takes time. Teaching requires prayer, discernment, and sensitivity to the spiritual maturity of the congregation. Trust that God works through process.

Continue to pray for your leaders. Encourage them even when progress feels slow. Unity is fragile, and wisdom often moves deliberately rather than quickly.

Invite Broader Discipleship, Not Just Sermons

If the pulpit does not feel like the right place for every issue, suggest other faithful contexts. Classes, small groups, forums, and recommended resources can help believers grow without politicizing Sunday worship. The early Church taught publicly and relationally. Formation happens in many spaces. Faithful teaching does not always require a microphone.

End With Prayer and Shared Commitment

Close the conversation with prayer. Commit yourself to being part of the solution. Be willing to serve, to learn, and to walk with others through difficult conversations.

The goal is not to make the Church louder, but clearer. Not more political, but more faithful. When the Church speaks with biblical conviction and pastoral love, it offers the world something rare and deeply needed.

Healthy conversations build healthy churches. Speak with truth. Listen with humility. Love with courage.

Continue Reading

Advice
January 28, 2026

The Elephant in the Room

Let's talk about Immigration & Customs Enforcement.
Written by
Tanner DiBella

Subscribe for news and insight.

We only share insightful and genuine content.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Don’t worry, we never share your email address.